Final Report of the CARB Expert Subgroup on " Comparative and Alternative Modeling Approaches
ثبت نشده
چکیده
Disclaimer: While the subgroup benefited from the active participation of its members, not all members had the opportunity to fully participate in the drafting of this final document. Therefore, these recommendations do not necessarily represent full concurrence by all subgroup members and in general should not be considered as necessarily supported by the organizations they represent. As land use change occurs constantly, and has always done so for a variety of interacting reasons, it is inherently difficult to isolate a single causative factor from many in a complex system involving diverse social, economic and ecosystem processes. Most current estimates of GHG releases caused indirectly by biofuels use economic equilibrium or partial equilibrium models to attribute conversion of uncultivated land to replace biofuel feedstock production on existing farmland.. These models were created primarily to analyze domestic farm policy, international trade and trade policies, with land use change mechanisms constructed to help achieve this analytical end. For CARB, however, the estimation of land use change is the analytical objective. The use of estimates of LUC for regulatory purposes is new and the basis for the estimations rapidly developing. Given the evolving nature of LUC estimation and the lack of a consensus model for LUC assessement, multiple, independent methods should be considered. Committee Recommendations: CARB should develop protocols for evaluating and comparing different types of methods for estimating ILUC. 1. Continue to improve GTAP's capacity to predict land change response globally in response to a change in domestic biofuel production. In particular, continuous improvements in data on land use and availability, estimation of important parameters governing land conversion and technology improvement and adoption are necessary. Committee recommendations: If CARB continues to rely soley on GTAP to estimate ILUC GHG values, then GTAP must be continuously improved for this purpose, within the limits of regulatory stability and predictability. All models need continuous updating and improvement to reflect the latest knowledge and data available. Particularly needed are improved data on global
منابع مشابه
Defining Neighborhood, Analysis of Two Different Approaches: Expert-oriented Approach of Theorists and Perceptual Approach of Residents
The different offered definitions of “Neighborhood Unit” in various approaches and viewpoints by different specialized views, on the one hand; and excessive attention to expert-oriented and reduced viewpoints as well as neglecting residents’ perception of the neighborhood on the other hand necessitate providing a complete and exact definition of neighborhood which can cover all approaches a...
متن کاملThe Economic and Welfare Effects of Different irrigation Water Pricing Methods, Case study of khomein Plain in Markazi Province of Iran
The scarcity of water resources and supply resources limitation, have caused an increasing gap between water supply and demand specially in recent decades in almost all regions of the globe. One of the best known solutions proposed by the economists is using the different water pricing approaches thereby obtaining the optimal allocation and social justice. To this purpose, this paper uses the p...
متن کاملParaphrasing the meaning of physical environment comparative examining of audience-oriented, author-oriented and text-oriented (Islamic) approaches
Discussions derived from epistemology and its sub-branches are of the most important theoretical grounds affecting theoretical basis of art schools in particular architecture styles. During recent decades, two approaches of epistemology have been reciprocally shaped to know how one can paraphrase the meaning of physical environment. In the first approach, the audience and his knowledge are main...
متن کاملA Comparative Study of the Views of Kristjansson, Battaly and Martyr Motahhari on the Effect of Theoretical Wisdom and Modeling on Moral Character
“Moral character” is a subject related to the psyche and an important topic in moral psychology. The question is whether the formation of moral character is inherent and unchangeable. If it is acquired, what factors affect it? If a character becomes vicious, is it possible to correct it? Considering the importance of the aforementioned questions, it was necessary to study the issue of “shaping ...
متن کاملApplication of PROMETHEE method for green supplier selection: a comparative result based on preference functions
The PROMETHEE is a significant method for evaluating alternatives with respect to criteria in multi-criteria decision-making problems. It is characterized by many types of preference functions that are used for assigning the differences between alternatives in judgements. This paper proposes a preference of green suppliers using the PROMETHEE under the usual criterion preference functions. Comp...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
دوره شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2010